DIY Frosty Paws Dog Treats

I don’t know about any of you, but both my dogs go BANANAS for frozen treats. It’s like their kryptonite after a long day of playing outside or a beach trip. One thing that irks me about store-bought treats is the price, so I’ve been trying to create as many as I can at home with things I already have in my house. Insert: DIY Frosty Paws Dog Treats

DIY Frosty Paw Dog Treats

Today I’m sharing a dupe for Frosty Paws – the frozen treats you can usually find in the stores. I wanted to find a way to make them at home so I knew every single ingredient that was going into them. This is for two reasons: 1. Judy is allergic to so many things that even just a smidgen of something can make her flare up, which means a nightmare for me. and 2. I like being able to say – hey, this is EXACTLY what is in there and be confident in what I’m feeding the dogs.

DIY Frosty Paw Dog Treats

For this recipe you will need:
1/2 cup homemade peanut butter (I make my own, but store bought would be find. Just make sure it doesn’t contain xylitol!)
1 cup plain yogurt (Greek yogurt is fine!)
2 tbsp. vegetable broth (or chicken if your dogs don’t have a chicken allergy!)

DIY Frosty Paw Dog Treats

1. Mix all the ingredients in a large bowl.
2. Distribute evenly into a large ice cube tray or other mold. You can snag my paw print silicone mold here.
3. Freeze for 12 hours, or overnight.

DIY Frosty Paw Dog Treats
4. Treat your pup!

DIY Frosty Paw Dog Treats


  • Andrea Nine

    Absolutely adorable and are Daisy grow and love them!

  • Jen

    Emma thanks you in advance for this recipe haha.

    • Kait

      You are SO welcome sweet Emma πŸ™‚