Considering adding a cashmere sweater from Everlane to your closet this season? Read my honest review of Everlane’s Cashmere Boxy Crew Sweater first.
When it comes to building a wardrobe I actually want to wear, I’m a big believer in investing in quality basics. I love pieces that feel elevated without being overly trendy, and a good sweater is one of those things I know I’ll reach for year after year. That’s exactly what drew me to the Cashmere Boxy Crew Sweater from Everlane.

I Splurged On A Cashmere Sweater From Everlane – Was It Worth It?
I purchased the sweater in Light Heather Grey, and after wearing it, I can confidently say it’s a piece I’m happy to have in my closet. From the relaxed fit to the incredibly soft material, there’s a lot to love about this cashmere sweater. Of course, it does come with a higher price tag, so I’m breaking down what I like, what I would change and whether I think it’s worth the investment.

The Fit Is Exactly What I Want in a Sweater
One of my favorite things about this sweater is the fit. As the name suggests, it has a boxy cut that feels relaxed and effortless without looking oversized or shapeless. I love that it gives you a little extra room without swallowing you up in fabric. I have been looking for this cut of sweater ever since I bought one at Target a few years ago that I LOVED, but just didn’t hold up to wear. It was like $25 and more than half of it was synthetic materials, so I guess that makes sense, but I digress. I loved that thing, so finding something higher in quality with the same cut…cue: angels singing.
The Cashmere Is Incredibly Soft
Let’s talk about the material, because this is where the sweater really shines for me, as noted above.
The cashmere is super soft, with that luxurious feel you want when investing in a nicer sweater. Even better, it doesn’t feel bulky. Some sweaters can be thick and heavy, making them difficult to layer or uncomfortable to wear indoors once the heat is on. This one strikes a really nice balance between feeling cozy and remaining lightweight. Everlane makes this sweater with 100% cashmere, including a blend of recycled and responsibly sourced cashmere. I appreciate that the brand has incorporated recycled fibers without sacrificing the soft feel I look for in cashmere.
The fabric also has a nice drape, which complements the boxy shape rather than making it feel stiff.

It Wears Well and Is Easy to Style
I always consider how often I’ll realistically wear something before deciding whether it’s worth buying. With this sweater, I can see myself reaching for it throughout the cooler months and based on how often I wore the cheaper style from Target, I know I will get my money’s worth.
The neutral gray shade is versatile, and the classic crewneck design makes it easy to pair with pieces I already own. It’s the kind of sweater that works for multiple occasions without feeling like I’m wearing the same outfit every time.
There Are So Many Color Options
Another selling point is the range of colors available. I went with Light Heather Grey because I something neutral that would work with just about everything in my closet, but there are plenty of other shades to explore. I can absolutely understand why someone would want this sweater in more than one color. The combination of the fit, softness, and versatility makes it easy to imagine wearing it on repeat and to be honest, I’m already trying to figure out what color to get next.
The One Downside: The Price
The biggest drawback for me is the price. Cashmere is an investment, and Everlane’s Cashmere Boxy Crew Sweater is not an inexpensive purchase at $178. Depending on the color and current promotions, the price can vary, so I’d recommend checking the website before buying. That said, I think there’s a difference between purchasing something expensive and purchasing something you’ll actually wear. A sweater that feels great, fits well and works with the rest of your wardrobe has a better chance of earning its place in your closet than something you buy on impulse and wear once. I knew I’d get a ton of wear out of this, because I had been looking for this silhouette since the Target sweater debacle.
Would I love it if the sweater were less expensive? Absolutely. Would I consider buying another one in a different color? Also yes.
Is the Everlane Cashmere Boxy Crew Sweater Worth It?
My verdict: Yes, grab one!
I really like the Everlane Cashmere Boxy Crew Sweater. The boxy fit is flattering without being too oversized, the cashmere feels incredibly soft, and the lightweight material makes it comfortable to wear on its own or layer under a coat. It’s a versatile piece that feels elevated without being fussy.
The price is the biggest consideration, but if you’re looking to invest in a classic cashmere sweater you’ll want to wear regularly, I think this one makes a strong case for itself. My advice? Choose a color you’ll wear constantly, check for a sale and take good care of it.
If you liked this post, you might also enjoy The Best Places To Buy Women’s Sweaters
My Honest Balzac Paris Cyrius Jacket Review
I Finally Got The Naghedi St. Barths Tote – Here Are My Honest Thoughts
I Own 4 Pairs of Cushionaire Sandals – Here’s My Honest Review